Overture's Data Retention Policy - Effective September 24, 2025 #422
Replies: 4 comments 3 replies
-
|
GDPR “right to be forgotten” is about proper storage of individual’s personal data. I’m sure this deletion policy is being implemented for good reasons, but I’m surprised (and a bit disappointed) to hear that it means Overture data files will go away after 60 days. I don’t think other publicly available map datasets typically work this way. Admittedly I am viewing this from a US-perspective, but data like TIGER, NAD, NLCD are available indefinitely, and people regularly use historical copies of these datasets to better map and understand how the world changes over time. More directly related to my work, the datasets that we make available in the Rapid editor are stable (generously hosted by Esri, Meta, Microsoft) and I have never even considered the possibility that they might be subject to GDPR’s right to erasure - it’s building footprints and addresses, not checkins or telemetry. In any case, I hope I am misunderstanding what this announcement means. I’m sure people with more experience with the GDPR than me have put a lot of thought into it and decided this for good reasons. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Bryan is right. The GDPR deals with personal data and should not be equated with trying to erase data history and lineage. That would be a misinterpretation. Besides, it doesn't help much that Overture Maps no longer offers data history, since the internet never "forgets" anything anyway. Are there any other reasons for this (non-)retention policy? And should'nt there be a bold news or blog post about these fundamental changes in this new policy and schema design (i.e. multi-licensing which would help integrating other data, especially OSM data)? |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
I would like to point out that from a scientific perspective, this decisions renders relying on OvertureMaps as very problematic as the work that pulls the Overture Data is fully reproducible for a maximum period of 60 days after which the data likely changes. I just ran into this when trying to reproduce my own work that was using the release from August '24, which no longer exists on S3. Since then, not only the data but I believe that also the schema have changed rendering the whole pipeline unusably any longer. I am not sure what is the position of Overture Foundation regarding support of reproducible scientific workflows but this specific change just killed any attempt to do any reproducible science on top of your data product. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Is there any update for the direction of data retention policy? While Overture Maps heavily relies on OpenStreetMap (even Places), it does not have such retention policy for "right to be fogotten" in the context of GDPR compliance (link). Also GDPR is not eligible to all the countries, but limited regions especially European Union. As Martin pointed, this change deteriorated the utility of this data product in terms of reproducibility. In my academic project, I collected the data from 2024 before but now not available anymore, so decided to use OSM unfortunately. While Dana said many applications are for the current data, there could be more needs like me or Martin. If the current stance holds for long term, many of business applications and academic research would have to turn back to OSM once they need to secure the temporal cutoff. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
Starting with our
2025-09-24.0release, Overture will implement a data retention policy for publicly available data releases.What's changing:
What remains available:
Why we're implementing this:
This policy ensures compliance with data protection regulations, including GDPR "right to be forgotten" requirements.
You can find complete details about our release schedule and policies on our Releases page. Questions? Feel free to ask in this discussion thread.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions